EIUG Submission Summary on NERSA Market Inquiry on Electricity Charges – 17 November 2025

Briefing Note: Key Issues from EIUG Submission to NERSA Market Inquiry

Date of Presentation: 17 November 2025
Presented by: Energy Intensive Users Group of Southern Africa (EIUG)
Inquiry Focus: Impact of Eskom’s Retail Tariff Plan (RTP), including fixed charges and Generation Capacity Charge (GCC)

1. Background

The EIUG, representing about 40% of South Africa’s electricity consumption and contributing 22% to GDP, participated in NERSA’s Market Inquiry to assess the implications of recent tariff and structural changes introduced under Eskom’s RTP and MYPD6. The EIUG provided scenario-based modelling analysis to illustrate potential impacts Instead of submitting actual billing data which it does not have. However, members were encouraged to submit their actual consumption and billing data directly to NERSA.

2. Key Findings from Scenario Modelling

Various scenarios were modelled but only two load profile scenarios were considered for the public hearing:

  • Scenario 1: Constant load at 90% of Notified Maximum Demand (NMD) year-round
  • Scenario 2: 90% NMD in Low Demand Season (LDS), 50% in High Demand Season (HDS)
  • Result: Tariff increases for Megaflex customers ranged from ~11% to over 18%, exceeding the average 12.74% increase. Escalations reached nearly 20% for some customer categories, especially those with lower voltage and longer transmission distances.

A more substantive quantitative analysis was shared with the regulators as a separate presentation that was also shared earlier with NERSA before the Market Inquiry was decided.

3. EIUG’s Core Concerns

Issue Concern
Affordability & Competitiveness Tariff hikes exceed inflation, threatening industrial viability.
Cross-Subsidies Embedded subsidies act as an “industrial input tax,” distorting market signals.
TOU Structural Changes Revised Time-of-Use (TOU) periods penalise load-shifting, especially during HDS.
Fixed Charges & GCC While reduced fixed charges at higher voltages are welcomed, the GCC lacks transparency and is applied unevenly between Eskom and wheeling customers.

4. Market Design & Systemic Risks

  • High Fixed Charges: May deter investment in behind-the-meter solutions like PV and storage.
  • Vesting Contracts: Could insulate Eskom from market competition, risking inefficiencies.
  • Cost Escalations: Eskom’s rising costs (e.g., 23% increase in employee benefits) are misaligned with industry norms.
  • Asset Valuation Disputes: Settlements (e.g., R54bn) may inflate revenue requirements and impose more burden to consumers.
  • Distorted Economics: GCC and Affordability Charges inclusion in wheeling offsets undermines private generation viability, particularly implemented projects.

5. EIUG Recommendations

a. Regulatory Oversight & Transparency
– Publish GCC methodology and cost assumptions.
– Benchmark Eskom’s charges internationally.
– Harmonize GCC application across Eskom and wheeling customers.

b. Tariff Design & Cost Reflectivity
– Reassess TOU ratios and reallocated hours.
– Limit fixed charges in generation to preserve market signals.

c. Market Transition & Affordability
– Conduct plant-level viability assessments before vesting contracts.
– Provide transitional support for energy-intensive users.
– Monitor and manage cross-subsidies.

d. Stakeholder Engagement & Data Integrity
– Use verified billing data and scenario modelling for decision making.
– Facilitate inclusive public hearings.
– Enforce compliance with approved tariffs.

6. Conclusion

EIUG emphasises that the cumulative impact of electricity price increases culminating in MYPD6 and RTP has rendered electricity unaffordable for many industrial users, leading to plant downscaling and closures. The EIUG urges NERSA to:

  • Allow sufficient consultation time for more impactful and major decisions.
  • Model impacts comprehensively across customer categories for decision making.
  • Ensure equitable, transparent, and economically sustainable tariff structures.

About the EIUG

The EIUG was established in 1999, and is a voluntary, non-profit association of energy intensive consumers whose members currently account for over 40% of the electrical energy consumed in South Africa. As electricity is a key input to the processes of these organisations, it is the ‘life blood’ of our businesses. Our members collectively contribute over 20% to the GDP of South Africa and employ over 650 000 people across multiple sectors, including mining, quarrying, manufacturing, electricity, transportation, and water. The EIUG is dedicated to the promotion of the interests of energy users in South African Industry.

The EIUG is a member-led organisation working for the good of the country. The group strongly believes that energy is the engine for economic growth and development in South Africa. We are therefore committed to working with government, power utilities and other stakeholders to ensure South Africa has energy industries which provide reliable supply at acceptable quality and competitive prices.

Energy Intensive Users Group of Southern Africa NPC
2019/478422/08
www.eiug.org.za
info@eiug.org.za